Imagine your business has just approved its marketing strategy for the coming year.
The proposed investments are supported by data. Your team understands its responsibilities, and everyone is confident about what needs to be delivered.
But what if the strategy achieves its targets and still leaves your business in a weaker position five years from now?
Perhaps you're acquiring more customers, but they're becoming less profitable. Perhaps revenue is growing, but maintaining that growth requires increasingly expensive advertising. Or perhaps you're successfully reaching the customers you already know while overlooking entire groups of potential buyers.
That's an uncomfortable possibility, particularly when capable people have invested considerable time and effort into developing the plan.
Yet for business owners, the quality of the decision may matter considerably more than how efficiently the subsequent work is delivered.
Good Execution Doesn't Always Mean Good Decisions
Most established businesses already have knowledgeable people responsible for marketing.
Internal teams understand their products and customers. Agencies contribute specialist expertise. Sales and customer-service teams bring valuable perspectives from their daily interactions.
Their contributions are essential.
But executing an agreed strategy and independently questioning whether that strategy remains appropriate are two different responsibilities.
A marketing director may have legitimate performance targets to achieve. An agency may be contracted to deliver specific outcomes. Senior leadership may have already committed significant resources to an initiative.
None of this means they're incapable of challenging decisions. Many do so exceptionally well.
But existing commitments, organizational expectations, and commercial incentives can make certain questions harder to raise.
Sometimes the most valuable contribution comes from someone prepared to question not how a strategy is being delivered, but whether it should be pursued at all.
Are we delivering the plan well?
Campaign performance, efficiency, targets and delivery.
Was this the right plan to pursue?
Customer value, alternatives, commercial returns and long-term consequences.
Five Questions That May Change Your Marketing Decisions
1. If We Were Starting Again Today, Would We Make the Same Investment?
Established strategies carry years of decisions, relationships, systems, contracts, and professional commitments.
Some are valuable assets. Others may remain in place because changing direction would be costly, inconvenient, or uncomfortable.
Imagine allocating your marketing budget again today, without feeling obligated to justify previous investments.
Would the same channels, agencies, initiatives, and customer segments receive the same resources?
If not, what is preventing you from reconsidering them?
An investment that made perfect sense three years ago isn't necessarily the best investment today.
Acknowledging that isn't admitting failure. It's recognizing that markets, customers, and business priorities evolve.
2. Are We Attracting the Customers We Actually Want?
A business might exceed its lead-generation targets while attracting increasingly unsuitable customers.
Perhaps those customers negotiate heavily on price, require disproportionate support, or rarely develop into valuable long-term relationships.
The marketing dashboard may still look excellent.
But would the business be better served by generating fewer inquiries from more commercially relevant buyers?
There's also another possibility.
Companies naturally become effective at reaching the audiences they already understand. Their marketing, communications, and sales processes gradually evolve around those customers.
Meanwhile, potentially valuable buyers may be researching different problems, using unfamiliar terminology, or seeking guidance before recognizing which solution they need.
Are you reaching the full range of customers your business could genuinely serve, or primarily those your current strategy is already designed to attract?
Not every potential customer is worth pursuing. The challenge is distinguishing deliberately excluded opportunities from those the business may never have examined.
The same business. Different starting points.
"I need a supplier for this service."
The buyer already knows the category and what to look for.
"How can we solve this recurring problem?"
The buyer may need your expertise without knowing what to search for.
3. How Much of Our Reported Growth Are We Actually Creating?
Marketing attribution tells us which activities receive credit for customer acquisition.
It doesn't necessarily tell us which activities caused those customers to purchase.
Some customers might have bought anyway. Others may have interacted with several channels before converting.
A campaign can appear commercially successful without contributing as much incremental value as its reporting suggests.
This raises a difficult question:
If we stopped this investment tomorrow, how much profitable business would we actually lose?
Answering that may require experimentation, incrementality analysis, and a better understanding of customer behavior.
Sometimes the evidence will justify investing more. Sometimes it may reveal that the apparent contribution of an activity has been overstated.
Either outcome is useful when allocating limited resources.
4. What Do Our Existing Customers Know That Future Customers Don't?
Consider the questions customers repeatedly ask after purchasing.
Perhaps they discover an unexpected benefit, encounter an implementation concern, or realize that a product solves a problem they hadn't originally associated with it.
The sales or customer-service team may hear the same observations repeatedly.
But are those lessons helping prospective customers before they make their purchasing decisions?
A manufacturer might worry about production disruption when considering new equipment. A professional-services buyer might hesitate because they don't understand what implementation involves.
Existing customers may already have experiences that address those concerns.
If that knowledge remains confined to individual conversations, the business may be overlooking opportunities to build confidence much earlier in the buying journey.
The question isn't simply whether you're collecting feedback.
It's whether the knowledge gained from serving customers is improving how future customers discover, evaluate, and choose your business.
Turn customer experience into buyer confidence
Recurring concerns · Unexpected benefits · Implementation experiences
Clear explanations · Relevant examples · Answers to objections
Better expectations · Greater confidence · More informed decisions
5. What Will Remain Valuable When Today's Marketing Investment Ends?
A successful marketing investment should create a positive commercial return.
But for owners building businesses intended to endure, there's another consideration.
What will remain valuable several years after the investment?
Will the business have stronger customer relationships, greater market understanding, improved capabilities, and a more trusted reputation?
Or will future leadership inherit a growth model that requires progressively greater expenditure simply to maintain its position?
This doesn't mean advertising is inherently inferior to organic acquisition, or that short-term investments are necessarily poor decisions.
Both can create substantial long-term value.
The important question is whether the investment strengthens the business's future position or merely improves its immediate results.
When the Better Recommendation Isn't the Bigger Project
In one engagement with a global organization, a substantial website redesign and technical overhaul were being considered, potentially requiring months of work across multiple engineering teams.
While these improvements had genuine technical merit, the more important question was whether they addressed the underlying business challenge.
My recommendation was to reconsider the investment priorities and first understand every major target audience, their different intentions, challenges, and touchpoints, including where potential users weren't discovering or interacting with the business at all.
Rather than committing substantial resources to improving the existing website, the proposed direction was to reach those audiences where their needs first emerged, providing relevant explanations, practical guidance, and solutions to the problems they were actually trying to solve.
The question was never whether the technical improvements would make the website better. It was whether they represented the best use of resources for the business's long-term growth.
Technical improvements and website redesigns can deliver considerable value. In different circumstances, the original proposal might have been the right recommendation.
The responsibility of an advisor isn't to recommend the most comprehensive solution. It's to recommend where the client's resources can create the greatest meaningful value.
Sometimes that means recommending a direction different from the one initially under consideration.
One business challenge. Two investment directions.
Improve the existing website
Redesign, technical upgrades and engineering resources.
Improve audience discovery
Understand user intentions, identify missing touchpoints and address real needs.
Why Difficult Conversations Are Part of Good Advisory
It's relatively easy to support a decision when everyone agrees.
It's much harder to explain why an apparently sensible investment may not be the best use of a company's resources.
A founder may be personally committed to an expansion. An internal team may have spent months preparing a project. A trusted agency may have developed a technically sound proposal.
Challenging that direction can be uncomfortable, particularly when substantial work has already taken place.
But the purpose of an advisor isn't to agree with leadership or challenge every decision for the sake of appearing insightful.
It's to provide the judgment the business needs, even when that judgment isn't what its leadership initially hoped to hear.
Doing so requires more than professional expertise.
It requires understanding the client's ambitions, respecting the reasoning behind existing decisions, and being willing to acknowledge uncertainty.
It also requires accepting the possibility that the original recommendation was correct.
A genuinely independent review may conclude that the existing strategy should continue unchanged.
That should be considered a valuable outcome, not a missed opportunity to recommend additional work.
Challenging a decision without undermining the people behind it
-
01
Understand the objective
What is the business actually trying to achieve?
-
02
Question the assumptions
What could be wrong, incomplete, or outdated?
-
03
Evaluate the alternatives
What other uses of these resources deserve consideration?
-
04
Support the decision
Agree on the direction and what evidence would justify revisiting it.
Independence Should Be Reflected in How Advice Is Paid For
There's another question business owners should consider:
Who benefits financially from the recommendations they're receiving?
An advertising agency might earn more when campaign expenditure increases. A consultant might benefit from recommending additional projects. An internal employee may have compensation linked to departmental performance or annual targets.
These arrangements don't make anyone dishonest or incapable of good judgment.
But commercial incentives can influence which recommendations are easier to make, which alternatives receive attention, and which conversations become uncomfortable.
This is where the structure of an advisory relationship matters.
I believe advisory fees should be transparent, agreed in advance, and independent of the financial value of the recommendations or their eventual implementation.
An advisor shouldn't earn more because a client decides to invest an additional million euros rather than retain that capital.
Equally, recommending that a client postpone an investment shouldn't create a financial penalty for the advisor.
A fixed fee doesn't automatically guarantee objectivity. An advisor may still feel pressure to retain a valuable client or avoid difficult conversations.
True independence requires both a compensation model that minimizes conflicting incentives and the personal integrity to act in the client's interests.
That includes the willingness to recommend doing nothing when doing nothing is genuinely the most appropriate decision.
The recommendation is based on the client's interests, not the size of the investment.
Invest
Proceed with a justified investment.
Redirect
Allocate resources differently.
Pause
Avoid or postpone an investment.
Building Relationships Where Disagreement Is Welcome
The most valuable advisory relationships aren't built on constant agreement. They're built on the trust to have difficult conversations when they matter.
The advisor develops an understanding not just of the company's marketing activities, but of its customers, commercial ambitions, financial constraints, and long-term priorities.
The business owner, in turn, learns whether the advisor can be trusted to exercise sound judgment, acknowledge mistakes, and put the business's interests ahead of their own.
That trust cannot be established through a single recommendation.
It develops through consistent behavior, particularly when circumstances become difficult.
For businesses intended to endure across generations, those relationships can become especially valuable. Leadership, markets, and technologies will change, but the need for reliable judgment remains.
An advisor's responsibility should therefore extend beyond identifying another opportunity or delivering another project.
The ambition should be to help owners make decisions they can stand behind, including those whose full consequences may not become apparent for years.
What should endure when people and circumstances change?
- Understanding of the client's business
- Institutional knowledge and decision history
- Independent judgment and shared principles
Before Your Next Significant Marketing Decision
Consider one final question:
If your proposed strategy were fundamentally wrong for your business's long-term future, who would recognize it, who would have the courage to tell you, and would you be prepared to listen?
The answer doesn't necessarily have to be an external advisor.
It might be your marketing director, financial controller, another member of leadership, or someone who has earned your trust over many years.
What matters is that the conversation can happen before an expensive decision becomes an expensive mistake.
Because sometimes the greatest value of good advice isn't the opportunity it helps you pursue.
It's the decision it helps you reconsider before the consequences become difficult to reverse.
Recommended next
Your Brand Is Supposed To Be Visible. But Is It Reaching the Right People?
Why visibility alone isn't enough, and how to ensure you're reaching the people who actually matter for your business.
Read article